Thankfully, after this sometimes profoundly depressing journey through the media’s use and abuse of Nature, there is a group of stories and a section of the media that takes Nature seriously, engages with it deeply, and nourishes our appreciation of its role in our lives as well as the wonder of its ‘otherness’.
We all know that serious journalism is finding it harder and harder to be heard in the Tower of Babel that is the modern mass media, but there are, and have been, fine pieces exemplifying the above; pieces that seek to explore and build, rather than tear down and subvert.
Section 1.1 ‘Articles’ contains examples of first-class writing about the environment and our relationship with it, so I will not reproduce them here. Some other examples of worthwhile environmental media are included below.
Dyani Lewis won the Finkel Foundation Eureka Prize for Long-Form Science Journalism in 2021 for a piece on coronavirus. Here, she tries to unravel the taxonomy, ecology and politics of Dingo classification and management in Australia.
Is a Dingo a Dog? The Answer Could Determine Its Future – The Atlantic
‘Dingoes Have Created a Scientific Rift’
Is classifying the wild dog as a species good strategy or bad practice?
By Dyani Lewis and Undark, 15-8-2019

The Atlantic is, of course, not the mass media; it is a serious magazine, but at least it shows that more thoughtful, balanced pieces can be written. Differing viewpoints are presented and respected, and above all, the article is about connection and context: what does a seemingly dry taxonomic debate have to do with the Dingoes’ fate and what impact will that have on Australia’s environment. No need for identifying enemies, no agendas and straw men, no danger or cute angles, no ideological axes to grind: straight, clear and interesting prose, as if the environment mattered.
(Note: There have been recent proposals to re-introduce dingoes into natural areas where they once lived as an ‘apex predator’. Currently, these calls have largely been rejected. This is a worldwide debate of much interest, whether it be re wolves, bears, tigers, eagles, or mountain lions).
Attempting to conform to the ‘mass media’ brief of this section, worthwhile pieces are harder to find. I have included the following from the mass-circulation ‘Los Angeles
Times’ because it demonstrates an interesting blend of mass-media populism and framing, and more serious comment and environmental context and concern; it is a sort of ‘half-way house’, or a bridge, between the shallow and the meaningful.
‘Reported Sighting of ‘Extinct’ Woodpecker Drives Bird-watchers Batty’
Brett Martel, 19-11-2000

First, the tedious framing: bird-watchers are weird and ‘batty’ (what is it with sub-editors and their headlines!), the sighting has caused “a considerable squawk”, and
the swamp is uninviting and dangerous. Ho hum. (Compare this with Carl Hiaasen’s depictions of the extraordinary swamps and wetlands of this ‘southern world’: Section 1.3.10).
After we’ve delivered the tired stereo-types, it seems, thankfully, that we can get to some substance: the bird is ‘majestic’ and possibly extinct, and “it represents the primeval forests of America – sort of a lost heritage of the virgin forests of SE USA”; and, most importantly, the causes of it decline and its environmental context are referenced: its habitat has all but been eliminated by “massive logging” making it doubtful that there is anywhere for it still to be found. (This is a shock: ’habitat’ is almost never mentioned in modern-day environment stories).
If I had set-up this story and wanted to send a strong conservation message about extinction, habitat, logging and swamplands in the USA, I would probably accept the article as a reasonable outcome for dealings with the mass media; it is a compromise between the media’s ‘needs’ and environmentalist desires. More on this interplay in webpage 6.8.
Note: Despite the glimmer of hope in the above article, and numerous searches, the Ivory-billed Woodpecker has now (2021) been listed as officially extinct. Read more here: U.S. declares ivory-billed woodpecker and nearly two dozen other species extinct – The Washington Post .
A third, and final, example of better mass-media environment stories is the ‘War on Waste’ series that I believe started in Britain with BBC’s ‘Hugh’s (Fearnley-Whittingstall’s) War on Waste’ in 2015, and was re-created in Australia by the ABC in 2021. It can be viewed here:
The ABC version had Craig Reucassel (a comedian in his other life), fronting it, and he was brave to do so as I imagine most media people when asked if they would do a show
on waste would run away screaming, “They hate me, they hate me!”. Despite this, they made a good attempt to address a topic no one wants to think about, and made it engaging and important.
The host has a lively, friendly manner that gets people on-side, and he is good at converting hard-to-understand figures and volumes (the ‘scale’ problem alerted to elsewhere in T10), to meaningful quantities and examples (e.g. the Melbourne tram full of disposable coffee cups).


At times, the four programs are perhaps a bit too directed at the individual and what he/she can do, and not enough ‘up-scale’ and strategically, at collective centres of power, such as the advertising industry, but this is defensible because he is trying to engage, as he says, “everyday Aussies”, and to make the topic understandable (much as T10 thinks the individual scale is a good starting – but not finishing – point for engaging with many environment issues). This said, he does, at times, deal with powerful, structural players, like supermarkets and politicians, but doesn’t go further to their need, and support of, constant growth, profit, and subsequent – waste.
The ABC and BBC should be congratulated on dealing with an obviously most ‘unsexy’ topic, and in an informative and engaging way, but critics will say that their engagement with ‘the environment’ is highly selective and limited (for instance, two thirds of T10’s ‘vital’ environment topics, such as #3 ‘Replace the Growth God’, or #9 ‘Economics and the Environment’, or #5 ‘Population’, or #7 ‘Habitat’, or even this section, ‘Media’ will never, or extremely rarely, appear) and thus this is Chomsky’s faux consultation, faux debate1, that creates the impression of diversity and dealing with issues while effectively excluding them and shutting them down. While I think this observation by Chomsky is perceptive and – sadly – often too true, application of this interpretation to ‘War on Waste’ would perhaps be ungenerous as the show was popular, effective, with a surprisingly large audience, and you would never see anything like this on most networks, certainly not commercial outlets. As such, I think the glass is half full on this one, not half empty.
1 Chomsky, N., Herman, E. 1988. Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. Pantheon Books, New York, USA.