Despite ‘Limits to Growth’ being published nearly 50 years ago, I am constantly amazed at how accurate their predictions and models have been, especially as it was achieved at a time of very limited computing power, and of patchy scientific data on the state of the natural world and of our activities upon it.
As Kerryn Higgs points out (Books # 4), its performance is better than any economic modelling – ever – and perhaps this is due, in part, to the ‘bleedin’ obvious’ that their central premise is irrefutably right, but this, of course, has not meant that it has in any way been accepted by the mainstream, or given the credit it deserves for its sharp perspicacity and the chance it gave the world to save itself, and life upon it.
In fact, not only has ‘Limits’ been ignored by those in power, it has been relentlessly attacked because it challenges the core belief of the new global religion: growth. PR agencies, advertisers, think tanks, business councils, media outlets and politicians have been queuing up to attack its carefully constructed truths with a mixture of deception, displacement, and downright appeals to magic (e.g. claims for growth for another 2,500 years, a population of 3.5 trillion, and infinite resource substitution as, resources are, apparently, only limited “in our minds”! Higgs p. 272).
Despite the above, more objective analysis, such as by Graham Turner at Australia’s premier scientific organisation – CSIRO – has found that the observed historical data from 1970 to 2000 closely match the simulated results of the ‘standard run’ limits of growth model for almost all the outputs reported. “The comparison is well within uncertainty bounds of nearly all the data in terms of both magnitude and the trends over time.”3 In other words, not only are the models correct, they confirm that when actual data from the present day is fed into them, that we have been tracking consistently at the worst-case-scenario level warned of by Meadows et al: that is, ‘business as usual’. For a person who has spent his adult life working for the environment, the failure to make any significant impression at all on our behaviour and impacts is deeply depressing.
1 Meadows, D. et. al. 1972. The Limits to Growth. Universe Books, New York, USA.
2 Meadows, D. et.al. 2004. Limits to Growth: The 30-year Update. Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction, USA.
3 Turner, G. 2008. A Comparison of ‘The Limits to Growth’ with 30 Years of Reality. Global Environmental Change, 18. Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands.